A universal guide for China studiesChinese Literature - Historic events thematically (jishi benmo 紀事本末) |
Encoding: Unicode (UTF-8) [Location: HOME > Literature > Historic events in their entirety : Tongjian jishi benmo][bottom]
Tongjian jishi benmo 通鑑紀事本末 "Historic events the 'Comprehensive Mirror' thematically in their entirety" | Literature by A to Z Literature by time Literature by theme | |
The biographical type of historiography as well as the chronological type of historiography both had their advantages and disadvantages. The former was concise in the descriptions of a person's life and performance and additionally provided the reader with information about important topics of government in the monographies; on the other side, many events are reported redundantly in several chapters, and the reader does barely learn about the historical circumstances before and after the life of a certain person. The chronological type helped the reader to have an overview of the flux of time and events over a whole period, but it does not provide him with the necessary background knowledge - and omitts the interesting encyclopedical part of the monographies of the biographical type of historiography. To know more about the development of factors that lead to a certain event and to learn about the outcome of intrigues, decisions and wars, the Southern Song scholar Yuan Shu 袁樞 (1132-1205) rearranged the material of the Zizhi tongjian to create a new type of historiography that he called jishi benmo 紀事本末 "reporting origin and result of historic events". While the Zizhi tongjian stayed the father of a new historiography and the Tongjian gangmu became the orthodox type of moralizing history, the Jishi benmo type became the popular style of historiography with dozens of writings, especially during the Qing Dynasty:
| ||
10. Wu and Shu on good terms 20th year of the era Jian'an "Establishing peace" of Emperor Han Xiandi. When LIU BEI still resided in Jingzhou (modern Wuhan), ZHOU YUY and GAN NING several times tried to pursue SUN QUAN to conquer Shu (modern Sichuan). SUN QUAN sent a messanger to LIU BEI, telling him: "LIU ZHANG is not fighting and will be unable to protect himself. If CAO CAO conquers Shu, Jiangnan will be in great danger. If somebody would first conquer the territory of LIU ZHANG (modern Sichuan) and then that of ZHANG LU, the whole south would be united, and even ten CAO CAOs would do no harm." LIU BEI answered: "The territory of Yizhou (modern Sichuan) is rich, but not easily accessible [...] Disputing about that matter, you can see that CAO CAO has been defeated at the Red Cliff, and could say that his force has vanished, he is nobody to worry about. But now, CAO CAO possesses already two parts of the three parts of China and wishes to drink his horses in the green sea and to show his soldiers in Wu and the capital Kuaiji. How could we stand this situation and sit there until we grow old? [...]" Translated by Ulrich Theobald |